Can privacy exist without security? 

Privacy and security are often discussed together, but they are not the same. Privacy is about protecting personal information and ensuring it is used appropriately. Security, on the other hand, involves the measures taken to protect data from unauthorised access, theft, or damage. These two concepts are deeply interconnected, and understanding the relationship between them requires a closer look at the CIA triad: confidentiality, integrity, and availability.

Confidentiality is the cornerstone of both security and privacy. It ensures that sensitive information is accessible only to those authorised to see it. For example, in healthcare, a patient trusts that their medical records are kept private. If a hospital’s systems are hacked and medical records are exposed, confidentiality is breached, and the patient’s privacy is compromised. Without strong security measures, such as encryption and access controls, it’s nearly impossible to maintain confidentiality. This makes clear that privacy cannot exist without the foundation of security.

Integrity focuses on maintaining the accuracy and reliability of information. It ensures that data is not altered or tampered with by unauthorised parties. In financial institutions, for instance, if an attacker changes the details of a bank transaction, it not only affects the integrity of the data but also undermines customer trust. Imagine your account balance being wrong because someone manipulated the data. Without integrity, privacy is also at risk. If personal information can be altered, individuals lose control over their data, making it impossible to ensure privacy.

Availability refers to ensuring that information and systems are accessible when needed. This is crucial for both privacy and security. For example, if an online portal managing personal data experiences a denial-of-service attack and goes offline, users cannot access their information. In such cases, the unavailability of systems disrupts people’s ability to exercise control over their private data. Thus, maintaining availability is as much a part of protecting privacy as it is of ensuring security.

Real-world examples highlight how privacy and security are intertwined. In 2017, the Equifax breach exposed the personal data of millions of people. The attackers exploited vulnerabilities in the company’s systems, breaching confidentiality. Once the information was stolen, it was used for identity theft and fraud. This breach underscores that without robust security, there is no way to guarantee privacy. Similarly, ransomware attacks lock users out of their systems, affecting availability. Victims cannot access their own data, violating their privacy as they lose control over personal information.

Another example is the GDPR, which sets strict requirements for organisations to protect personal data. Compliance with these regulations demands strong security practices, such as encrypting data and regularly assessing risks. Organisations that fail to secure data not only face fines but also risk losing customer trust. This demonstrates that privacy laws are rooted in the need for security measures.

It’s important to recognise that while security is essential for privacy, it doesn’t guarantee it. Security measures can protect data from being stolen, but they don’t dictate how it is used. For example, a company can have excellent cybersecurity systems but still misuse customer data for purposes the individual never agreed to. This highlights that privacy requires more than just security — it also needs governance, transparency, and ethical practices.

At the same time, privacy cannot exist in a vacuum without security. Personal data stored in an unprotected system is vulnerable to breaches, making privacy an empty promise. Consider a social media platform that fails to secure its users’ data. Even if the platform has a privacy policy, weak security undermines any assurance of privacy.

Privacy and security are two sides of the same coin. The CIA triad — confidentiality, integrity, and availability — provides the framework for understanding how security supports privacy. Without security, privacy is impossible to achieve. However, security alone isn’t enough to ensure privacy. Both must work together to protect personal data and uphold trust. Organisations must prioritise robust security practices while also respecting the rights and expectations of individuals regarding their personal information.

business a.m. commits to publishing a diversity of views, opinions and comments. It, therefore, welcomes your reaction to this and any of our articles via email: comment@businessamlive.com