There are stories that entertain society, stories that provoke outrage, and stories that ought to compel us to reconsider the values upon which our families, communities and institutions are built. The recent story of an involuntarily childless woman in Ukehe, Eastern Nigeria, whose experience of rejection, isolation and public humiliation has attracted remarkable attention across Nigeria and beyond, including across the continent and the global social and digital space, beckons our empathy and pricks our humanity.
Beyond the emotional videos, public sympathy, gifts, celebrations and the extraordinary show of solidarity by Nigerian youths and other people beyond Nigeria, there are much deeper social issues that demand our attention. These include questions about what happens to a woman when she does not become a mother within the expectations of her marriage and society.
Some of the numerous questions that challenge our collective conscience include: Does she cease to deserve affection? Does her place in her husband’s home become negotiable? Does her contribution to the family suddenly become insignificant? Does she lose her right to participate in family decisions? Must she endure humiliation because another woman has fulfilled the reproductive expectations that she could not? Why should an involuntarily childless woman sometimes suffer the loss of her marriage, dignity, identity, belonging and social recognition simply because she has not given birth?
Ukehe incident: A wife’s sacrifices and a woman’s place eroded
According to accounts circulating about the incident, the woman entered marriage as a young sweetheart, with the familiar hopes and expectations of building a family with the man she loved. They married in church and began their journey as husband and wife, anticipating that children would eventually become part of their shared experience. However, the years passed without the fulfilment of that expectation. Where motherhood is often treated as the ultimate evidence of a successful marriage, the absence of children can expose a woman to extraordinary emotional and social pressures.
In this particular account, the first wife reportedly supported her husband’s decision to marry another woman in the hope of having children. The second wife subsequently had five children. One would expect that the arrival of children would expand the family’s happiness and create opportunities for greater love, cooperation and shared responsibility. Instead, according to the woman’s account, her position in the family deteriorated. She reportedly became excluded from family decisions, alienated from the children and increasingly treated like a stranger in the home she had helped build. Even ordinary expressions of kindness became sources of conflict.
One incident involved clothing she had purchased as gifts for the second wife’s children. The gifts were returned, with the second wife expressing that she did not want gifts from her, apparently suggesting that accepting them could bring misfortune to her children. When the first wife sought her husband’s intervention, his response was dismissive. He maintained that nobody could be compelled to accept a gift and saw nothing wrong with the conduct. She subsequently approached their priest, who recognised that the attitudes displayed by the husband and second wife were wrong and urged the husband to return home and resolve the issues in his family. Sadly, the reported mistreatment continued. Eventually, the woman could no longer bear the emotional burden and left the marital home for her father’s compound.
Then came another painful chapter. When her husband was to receive a traditional chieftaincy title in their community, she was not informed in the manner one might reasonably expect of a wife. Nevertheless, she attended the occasion. During the public recognition of wives and women, she was overlooked, sidelined and left out. She broke down in tears.
But something remarkable happened. Members of the crowd noticed her distress and began rallying around her. People started recognising, appreciating and honouring her. Gifts of clothing and money followed. Nigerian youths, moved by her experience, began travelling to her community to celebrate her, calling her “Mother of the World” and showing her an extraordinary level of public affection. A woman who had experienced years of exclusion suddenly found herself surrounded by people who wanted her to feel seen. It was a powerful demonstration of compassion.
As we celebrate the kindness of these young Nigerians and other benefactors from within and beyond Nigeria, it is important not to allow the emotional beauty of this moment to distract us from the social tragedy that preceded it. Why did it take a public breakdown for this woman to receive the recognition, kindness and dignity that should never have been taken away from her?
Societal norms that mask the lives of involuntarily childless women
Across many African communities, there are unwritten rules that determine how women are treated based on their reproductive experiences. Nobody may formally announce these rules, but their consequences are visible in homes, extended families, religious institutions and community gatherings. Some of these unwritten rules include:
- A woman’s value is measured by her ability to give birth
A woman may be educated, financially responsible, emotionally supportive, generous and committed to her marriage. Yet, when children do not come, these contributions may be overshadowed by her reproductive circumstances. Her identity becomes reduced to what she has not achieved biologically.
- Motherhood gives a woman greater authority and social recognition
In some families, the arrival of children gives a second wife perceived superiority over the first. She may begin to enjoy greater recognition, influence and authority, while the first wife is gradually pushed into the background. Having children does not confer ownership of a husband, superiority over another woman or an automatic right to erase another woman’s place in a family.
- An involuntarily childless woman MUST be grateful for being tolerated
Some women are expected to tolerate disrespect, emotional neglect and even abuse because they are perceived to have fewer options. The implication is that they should not complain, challenge injustice or insist on their rights for fear of losing the marriage altogether. This is not patience. It is the normalisation of mistreatment.
- She must NOT appear happier, more successful or more fulfilled than women with children
There is sometimes an unspoken expectation that an involuntarily childless woman should remain subdued, apologetic and constantly conscious of her circumstances. When she expresses joy, celebrates achievements, pursues opportunities or lives purposefully, people question her happiness. Why should a woman apologise for finding joy in life simply because motherhood has not happened for her?
- Her generosity must never be mistaken for entitlement
When she gives gifts, supports children or contributes to family welfare, her intentions may be questioned. When she withdraws, she may be labelled bitter or jealous. She is placed in an impossible position where she cannot win, regardless of how carefully she conducts herself. These unwritten rules are not harmless cultural peculiarities. They create environments in which women are stripped of belonging, confidence, dignity and emotional security.
Misconceptions that continue to hurt involuntarily childless women
One of the greatest challenges facing the involuntarily childless community in Africa is the persistence of misconceptions about childless life. These misconceptions influence how families respond, how communities interpret events and how religious people counsel those experiencing reproductive challenges.
- Childlessness is always the woman’s fault
This is scientifically inaccurate and socially misrepresented. Infertility is a reproductive health condition that can involve male factors, female factors, both partners or unexplained causes. It cannot be accurately attributed to a woman simply because she is the one expected to become pregnant. Both partners deserve appropriate medical evaluation, compassion and respect.
- A woman without biological children has nothing meaningful to contribute to society
This is one of the most damaging assumptions. Women contribute through leadership, enterprise, mentorship, education, service, creativity, caregiving, innovation and community development. Their contributions do not become less valuable because they have not given birth.
- Having children gives a woman the right to mistreat another woman
Motherhood is a beautiful responsibility, but it is not a licence for superiority, cruelty or exclusion. A woman who has children should not use that privilege to diminish another woman’s dignity. Similarly, the presence of children should never be used as a weapon in marital disagreements or family power struggles.
- An involuntarily childless woman is necessarily jealous of women with children
This assumption is particularly unfair. A woman may experience grief over her unfulfilled desire for motherhood while genuinely loving, celebrating and supporting women who have children. Two emotional realities can coexist. She can be happy for another woman’s pregnancy and still grieve her own experience. We must stop interpreting every emotional expression through the lens of jealousy.
- Once a man has children through another woman, his first wife becomes less relevant
Marriage is not a competition in which reproductive success determines who deserves respect. Where a man enters another marriage, especially within a polygamous arrangement, he assumes additional responsibilities. Those responsibilities do not cancel the dignity, rights or legitimate interests of an existing wife. A woman’s inability to conceive does not retrospectively invalidate the marriage she entered or erase the years, sacrifices and contributions she made.
- business a.m. commits to publishing a diversity of views, opinions and comments. It, therefore, welcomes your reaction to this and any of our articles via email: comment@businessamlive.com






